Asphalt vs. Steel vs. Rubber Roofing: Which Is Best for Your Appleton Home?
Choosing a new roof is a big decision — and it’s one that affects your home’s look, value, and long-term protection from Wisconsin’s weather. If you’re replacing your roof in the Appleton area, you’ve probably come across three popular options: asphalt shingles, steel roofing, and rubber roofing.
Each material offers unique advantages (and a few drawbacks), so let’s compare them side by side in terms of durability, cost, and appearance to help you find the best fit for your Appleton home.
Asphalt Roofing
The classic, affordable choice for Wisconsin homes.
Asphalt shingles are by far the most common roofing material you’ll see around Appleton — and for good reason. They’re cost-effective, easy to install, and come in a wide range of styles and colors.
Pros
- Budget-friendly compared to steel or rubber
- Attractive styles that mimic slate or wood
- Simple repairs and quick installation
- Reliable lifespan (15–25 years with proper care)
Cons
- Shorter lifespan than steel or rubber
- Can lose granules or curl over time
- More vulnerable to hail and high winds
Best for: Homeowners who want a traditional, economical roof that still looks great in the neighborhood.
Steel Roofing
Durability that stands up to Wisconsin’s toughest weather.
Steel (or metal) roofing is growing fast in popularity around the Fox Valley. While the upfront cost is higher, it can last 40–70 years — making it one of the most durable options available.
Pros
- Exceptional longevity and low maintenance
- Highly resistant to wind, hail, and snow
- Reflective surface improves energy efficiency
- Modern, upscale appearance that boosts curb appeal
Cons
- Higher initial investment
- Can be noisier during rain or hail (unless insulated well)
- Repairs or color matching can be more involved
Best for: Appleton homeowners who want long-term value, durability, and a contemporary look that stands out.
Rubber Roofing (EPDM or Modified Bitumen)
A smart, durable option for flat or low-slope roofs.
Rubber roofing isn’t as well-known for residential homes but it’s a strong contender for garages, additions, or commercial buildings. It’s made to resist leaks and handle extreme temperature changes.
Pros
- Excellent water resistance — ideal for low slopes
- Energy-efficient, helping moderate indoor temps
- Long lifespan (30–50 years) with minimal upkeep
- Highly recyclable and eco-friendly
Cons
- Limited aesthetic appeal for steep-slope homes
- Professional installation required for watertight seals
- Fewer color and style options
Best for: Flat or low-slope roofs, garages, or business properties needing watertight, low-maintenance protection.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Asphalt Shingles
Lifespan:
15–25 years
Initial Cost:$
Maintenance:
Moderate
Weather Resistance:
Good
Energy Efficiency:
Fair
Aesthetic Variety:
Excellent
Steel Roofing
Lifespan:
40–70 years
Initial Cost:$$$
Maintenance:
Low
Weather Resistance:
Excellent
Energy Efficiency:
High
Aesthetic Variety:
Moderate
Rubber Roofing
Lifespan:
30–50 years
Initial Cost:$$
Maintenance:
Low
Weather Resistance:
Excellent
Energy Efficiency:
High
Aesthetic Variety:
Limited
So, Which Roofing Material Is Best for Your Appleton Home?
It depends on what matters most to you:
- Want affordability and classic curb appeal? Choose asphalt shingles.
- Want the last roof you’ll ever need? Go with steel roofing.
- Need leak-proof performance on a flat roof or garage? Consider rubber roofing.
Whatever you choose, make sure your roof is installed by a licensed, local Appleton roofing contractor who understands Wisconsin’s weather and building standards.
Need Help Deciding? We’re Here for You.
At Affordable Contracting Services, we’ve been installing and replacing roofs across Appleton, Neenah, and the Fox Valley for over 25 years. Our friendly, local team can help you compare materials, review pricing, and find the perfect fit for your home and budget.
👉 Request your free roofing estimate or call (920) 216-2243.
Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in Wisconsin
What roofing material lasts the longest in Wisconsin?
Steel roofing typically lasts the longest — up to 70 years — and performs exceptionally well against Wisconsin’s snow, wind, and ice.
Are metal roofs noisy during rain or hail?
Modern steel roofs installed with quality insulation are not significantly louder than asphalt shingles. Most homeowners don’t notice a difference once installed correctly.
Can rubber roofing be used on houses?
Yes! While most common on flat or low-slope structures, rubber roofing (EPDM) can be a great option for certain residential projects like additions or garages.
What is the most affordable roofing option?
Asphalt shingles remain the most affordable choice for Wisconsin homeowners — offering great value, quick installation, and strong protection for the price.
How do I choose the right roofing contractor in Appleton?
Look for a licensed, insured, and local roofing company with solid reviews and experience in Wisconsin’s climate. Affordable Contracting Services has been a trusted name in the Fox Valley since 2003.
Share this article
Recent Posts
